Natural Killer to Kill or Transform?

Natural Killer cells emerge from distinct sources in embryonic development and each source of these earliest, innate immune cells confers different functions to the ascending cell lines. Fetal yolk sac, erythro-myeloid progenitor (EMP) derived NK cells, are uniquely biased for cytotoxic degranulation as opposed to inflammatory cytokine production, which are the dual hallmarks of all adult NK cells. But, parallel studies using human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) revealed that these progenitors can also give rise to NK cells that harbor a potent cytotoxic degranulation bias to kill.

In one of my previous articles, Natural Killer Shaping A Life I began to track processes supporting the unified origin of reproduction and immunity based on the theory of allorecognition.

Preceding implantation, the zygote divides to 16 cells that differentiate into an outer cell layer, trophoblast, and inner cell mass, embryoblast. The trophoblast becomes the fetal portion of the placenta, the embryoblast the embryo. Once differentiated into 30 cells a fluid-filled central blastocyst cavity forms. At about the 6th day of development, once it has reached nearly 100 cells the blastocyst mass begins its journey through the uterus to implant in the endometrium, which is where the embryo develops.

Yolk Sac

Implantation of the blastocyst is dependent, in part on a feto-maternal, immune handshake in which maternal NK cells of the Decidua (dNK), lining the Uterus are coerced by invading villus trophoblast cells to express cytokines that transform epithelial vascular cells in the placenta to release their binding enabling trophoblasts to replace them and  connect embryo to maternal blood supply  without rejection. This delicate phenomena is responsible for successful pregnancy. 

Following implantation, once cells of the inner embryoblast mass differentiate, only the cells of the yolk sac ultimately become the source of the NK cell of interest here. The other progenitor NK cell is sourced external to the yolk sac and that may also be basis of their functional differences.

The varied function of these dual sourced NK progenitors is transformation, as evidenced in trophoblast invasion, or killing damaged cells by cytolysis which the name "Natural Killer cell" describes. The dual source of the "killer" variety is thought to impart a WNT signaling influence over NK cell lineage. WNT-independent (WNTi-) and WNT-dependent (WNTd-) processes were found to distinguish the NK ontology. NK cells, biased toward degranulation and cell killing have been traced to the yolk sac, which remains isolated from rapidly differentiating external cells of the embryo until, over multiple weeks it gets fully absorbed.

dNK cells play an essential role in tissue and blood vessel transformation of the developing placenta. This has promoted an advanced body of thought that suggests certain tissue resident NK cells that possess some dNK characteristics may also be responsible for blood vessel transformation to accommodate new cancer or cancer stem cells that require new blood supply to develop into tumors. Therefore, cancer resident NK cells that, like dNK also express HLA-G or possess other trophoblast stem cell like characteristics may transform epithelial cells lining blood vessels in similar ways that connect fetal cells to the maternal blood supply without immune rejection.

To determine whether NK's varied ontology can shed any light on cancer cells coercing NK cells for tumor development and expansion, we identified the only three major gene expressions that are distinguished by their WNTi origin and which may inform about NK in adult mechanisms. Since our interest at Codondex is centered on p53 we correlated it with these genes:

1) NFIL3/E4bp4 transcription factor controls the commitment to NK lineage, directly regulates Eomes and ID2, which is responsible for P53 gain of function by suppressing ID2.

2) NCAM1/CD56 common NK gene is widely used to distinguish NK populations and strongly associated with p53 in multiple myeloma.

3) XBP1 a WNTi specific gene - regulates the p53/MDM2/P21 axis and is strongly present in yolk sac transcript analysis.  Unconventional splicing of XBP1 mRNA occurs in the unfolded protein response.

HLA-C is the only NK signaling molecule expressed by trophoblast cells that by a polymorphism can present variation for Adaptive immunity. Reduction of NK cytotoxicity was directly tied to the volume of Ets dependent expression from the site of the HLA-C polymorphism.  Further, Ets1, which is expressed in all NK ontologies, is necessary for a CBP/p53 transcription complex and transcription in UV-induced apoptosis in embryonic stem cells where the absence of p53 resulted in a high rate of embryonic malformations.

A possible scenario begins to emerge that near fully cytotoxic NK cells that bind HLA-KIR inhibiting and activating target cell receptors may be coerced to transcribe HLA-C, to express more inhibiting polymorphic or activating non-polymorphic transcripts, therefore greater or lesser Ets1 availability to coregulate XBP1 targets or CBP/p53 as the tipping point of degranulation and target cell killing.

A lesson on virus, COVID-19 a.k.a Coronavirus

COVID-19 - Coronavirus

In the field of genetics I study 'transposable elements', which are tiny fragments of inactive, viral DNA that were historically inserted into and survive in the genes of cells of living organisms. It's thought that human DNA developed, in part as a result of around 8% inserted viral DNA that became fragmented and interspersed among other protein coding or regulatory DNA. Further, the function of the vast majority of our DNA is unknown, we know its there, but we don't know exactly what it is there for.

A virus like Corona is a functioning arrangement of proteins that protect not its DNA but the product of DNA, its RNA. This unique arrangement of proteins ensures the RNA's survival as code to make the proteins that protect it. The virus, its protective protein and DNA or RNA will die if exposed. So, survival is dependent on hitching a ride in an organism and freeloading in a cell where, once inserted, the virus DNA or RNA may attract that cells DNA/RNA-replication-proteins.

If the inserted sequences are attractive, they will dominate the activity of that cells replication-proteins. After being replicated many-many times over, the co-opted cell will produce the virus protein and assemble it into more viruses that will eventually kill the cell and move on to other cells where the process will repeat. The protein arrangement of a replicating virus, binds to a cell membrane before injecting its DNA or RNA into that cell. Ultimately the activity may invite immune system cells to identify, fight and kill infected cells before the virus can replicate further.

In some viral genes DNA that has become separate 'transposable elements' or fragments can lie dormant in cell genes for very long periods and their positions in the gene can change. Sometimes long sequences of a genes DNA break, when this occurs viral fragments located near proteins, attracted to recombine the break may also be assembled with other DNA that make the viral fragment more or less attractive to DNA-replication-proteins.

COVID-19 is a much more simple-recent addition. It injects not DNA, but the post DNA replication product known as RNA. This occurs after the proteins of COVID-19 connect to a human cell at least via receptor known as ACE2. If you are healthy and your immune system finely tuned, in more than 99% of cases the infected cell will be killed and virus dismantled.

COVID-19 RNA Replication and Protein Assembly

The most recent data suggests every infected person is successfully passing COVID-19 to 2.5 other people, many of whom do not express symptoms. It is quite likely COVID-19 will tail off with the rising temperatures in the northern hemisphere. In 2003 other Coronaviruses, SARS peaked in March and April and was done by May. MERS appeared in 2012, peaked in spring of 2014, and hasn't spread since then. Although Corona may already be more widespread, it is likely the panic presently being experienced around the world will subside and not re-arise in the winter of 2020/21. Since RNA viruses are less resilient that DNA viruses, I predict, Corona will disappear from our radar screens and like most "fake news" we will look back, scratch our heads and deeply consider how we should assess future events like this one.

Natural Killers Responsive Through Transposable Elements

Mechanisms of immunity are generally referred through MHC, HLA, antigens and other molecules that describe the presentation and interaction of cell surface receptors with cells of the adaptive immune system. Innate immune interactions occur through inhibitory and activating receptors including on Natural Killer (NK) Cells, but rarely does research elucidate the genomic activity of the target cell and its relationship to upstream activities on the cell surface. 

Transposable Elements (TE's) are DNA sections of a gene that can change their location by insertion. They were a focus of our early work that included the study of repeats in intron's (regulatory sections of genes) and their potential relationship to protein expression. Interestingly the most recurrent TE's are among the youngest in the genomic evolutionary chain and are predominantly expressed from intergenic loci associated with antiviral or DNA damage responses. In Drosophila melanogaster, the genomic regions surrounding 84 TE's located near genes involved in stress response, behavior and development indicated an adaptive effect. Recently it has become more widely accepted that TE expression in tumors is associated with immune infiltration and increased antigenicity.

In plant immunity a TE has been domesticated for service through histone marks and generation of alternative mRNA isoforms that were both directly linked to response to a particular pathogen. In vivo, an intron1 site co-opted the TE-associated histone mark to facilitate epigenetic control of pre-mRNA processing, which established a unique mechanism for regulation of immune gene expression in plants. Although in vivo proof in animal or human cells is more complex to obtain, increasing amounts of research has been directed to determine whether TE's are a widely deployed, histone associated, epigenetic mechanism for gene expression.

p53 transcription sites evolved through epigenetic methylation, deamination and histone regulation that constituted a universal mechanism found to generate various transcription-factor binding sites in short TE's or Alu repeats. A study into the evolution of immune antigen receptor's (AgR's) proposed their origin from NK-like receptors that recognized MHC-like molecules. The team went on to provide evidence of such. They found that all AgR rearrangements are likely derived from the huMHCpara-19 precursor by invasion of a TE on the RAG gene that was split, by double-stranded DNA breaks (DSB) at variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) segments that could also be recombined. In mature NK cells recombination of the V and J element does not frequently occur, but in immature NK precursor populations RAG altered heterogeneity, cytotoxic capacity, cellular fitness and differentiation.

To persist RAG DSBs must escape efficient repair, avoid the activation of p53 cell death pathways, dissociate from their post-cleavage complex, associate with other DSBs to which they will ultimately join and successfully navigate end joining pathways. In lymphocyte precursors of scid's patients (severe combined immunodeficiency) RAG V J recombination activates a p53-dependent DNA damage checkpoint.

Mutant NK cells lacking RAG activity or Wild Type NK cells lacking a history of RAG expression are more terminally differentiated and highly cytolytic, but characterized by greater apoptosis following DNA damage. In contrast, WT NK cells with a history of RAG expression are less terminally differentiated and cytotoxic but can generate long-life memory cells following antigen-specific proliferation, characterized by increased survival and ability to repair DSBs. Therefore, an unexpected functional RAG dichotomy exists between NK cell populations to effectively combat pathogens.

Natural killer cells do not rearrange DNA to generate antigen receptors and are thus innate immune cells. However NK cells do have reciprocal relationship with cells of the adaptive immune system. The integrated dynamics of TE's in RAG DSB's and p53 binding sites implicate innate and adaptive immunity mediated through diverse NK cell population, education and antigen production possibly dating back to MHC evolution and reproductive allorecognition in which p53 plays a central role.

189 gastrointestinal cancer patients across three cancer types: 95 stomach, colorectal esophageal were examined for any aberration in DNA repair pathways that could be associated with L1 retro-transposition. Out of 15 DNA repair pathways, only the TP53 repair pathway showed a significant association. L1 retro-transposition is inversely correlated with expression of immunologic response genes. Frequent TP53 mutations in tumors with a higher load of L1 insertions suggest the critical role of TP53 in restricting retrotransposons as a guardian of L1 expression and cancer immunity.

Impotent Natural Killers by Cancer Stem Cells and Ageing

Cancer stem cells have been found, through various mechanisms to alter the sentinel function and innate, immune surveillance of Natural Killer cells (NK). In senescent cells that have stopped cell division, including in cancer stem cell niches and NK induced vascular remodeling (as found in the developing placenta) NK's sentinel vigilance is also reduced.

Senescence-associated mitochondrial dysfunction, a significant trigger of multiple dimensions of the senescent phenotype is caused by disruption of normal mitochondrial autophagy (mitophagy). Mitophagy increases with aging and this age-dependent rise is abrogated by PINK1 or parkin deficiency. Deletion of a p53 response element on PINK1 promoter impacts p53-mediated PINK1 transcriptional repression. This p53-mediated negative regulation of autophagy has been found to be PINK1-dependent and constitutes a p53-PINK1 loop in nucleus and cytoplasm.

Further, mitophagy controls the activities of tumor suppressor p53 to regulate, at least hepatic cancer stem cells via Nanog. Prostate cancer cells escape NK attack by Nanog down-regulating ICAM1 (LFA1), to which NK would normally bind its target. In lung cancer NK have been found to limit the efficient clearance of senescent tumor cells from the mouse lung after p53 restoration. This indicated p53 may promote conditions for cellular survival and NK induced vascular remodeling or angiogenesis, necessary for the growth of tumors.

When under stress and inner mitochondrial membrane pressure gradient moves toward depolarization, Pink1 slots into the membrane, binds and phosphorylates p53 at Serine 392 (p53s392) and aids phagophore formation to enhance mitophagy. Mitophagy traps cytoplasmic p53s392, which reduces its transport to the nucleus where it would otherwise disrupt transcription of Nanog. (As illustrated below). 

Activated p53s392 nucleoside concentrations are effected by mitophagy

On the other hand, the sentinel function of NK may be subject to this PINK1 mediated mitochondrial switch. In prostate cancer cells Nanog promoted ICAM1 transcription required for NK binding target and cell killing. In prostate cancer cells Nanog over-expression restricts ICAM1, which promotes tumor formation. (As illustrated below). Investigating further, the direct functional link between p53 and ICAM-1 (CD54) in senescence and age-related disorders appears to be deeply integrated in mitophagy, senescence and immunity.

Nanog over-expression appears to be deterministic 

In stem cells where normal expression of Nanog transcribes ICAM1 and cancer stem cells where over-expression of Nanog restricts ICAM1, the variable PINK1-p53 switch may represent a "canary" that signals the state of  mitochondrial health to sentinel NK. However in some cancer cells where normal mitophagy is impaired and Nanog expression is restricted by p53s392, other p53 isoforms may directly promote the transcription of ICAM1.

In  two manipulation experiments using five different fibroblast cell lines that accelerated development of senescent associated secretory phenotypes a striking result was observed: oncogenic RAS expression, which causes genotoxic stress and senescence in normal cells, and functional loss of the p53 tumor suppressor protein. Both loss of p53 and gain of oncogenic RAS also exacerbated pro-malignant paracrine signaling activities. Experiments show that PINK1 and Parkin, which are regulated by p53 specifically regulate mitochondrial antigen presentation of both MHC classes.

So, the question is whether the p53-PINK1 mitochondrial switch acts as cell-health "canary" for sentinel NK, where its inherent variables and regulatory loop may be fertile ground for the challenges of developing cancers? 

Therapeutic Coding and non-Coding DNA Relationships

Relationships of coding and non-coding intra-gene DNA are good cause for intense research and scientific debate. Many cellular functions of non coding DNA have been discovered in the past 30 years, but prior to that these genomic regions were mostly considered 'junk'.

Probing relationships between a genes' protein coding, cDNA and at least one non-coding DNA section of the transcript, which in our work is intron1 can yield important data about genomic features in the combination. Over the past 7 years we focused on interrogating combination relationships, across multiple transcripts to construct intra-gene DNA signatures from apparently disparate DNA elements that are known to perform vastly different biological functions, yet are proximal and often adjacent.

First we considered codon to amino acid coding may operate a little different to the classical view if reading a first and second nucleotide made the third deterministic. This method would not alter the outcome of known protein coding, but it may alter the way we consider combination relationships between nucleotide's. For a transcript, any given length of cDNA and its respective intron1 sequence could possess undiscovered intrinsic order. In a model where order was tightly honored, transcript relativity may identify cDNA sequences that caused significant change in the order at each next nucleotide step.

To investigate transcripts, from the first nucleotide we computed every length cDNA k-mer. We associated k-mer's, of every possible length with the cDNA transcripts intron1 signature. Then, for a set of multiple same gene transcripts, in nucleotide order our algorithm ordered the transcripts into a vector based on their respective cDNA-kmer:intron1-signatures. Stepping through from one k-mer to the next we observed whether next k-mer significantly changed the order of transcripts in the vector. After filtering domino effects we ranked k-mers with the most significantly changed transcript order from the previous k-mer.  

Size of  circle 'K' in the example indicates k-mer length, but we only compare same length K

In the above example, it is evident that k-mer2 vs k-mer3 was the most changed because all three transcript positions moved without a domino effect. From the vector we identify intra:inter transcript conditions in next nucleotide relationships as represented in the k-mers. 

As an example, in our work with 15 viable consensus transcripts for p53 occasionally all 15 transcripts in the vector changed positions at the next k-mer. These intra transcript k-mer relationships govern the transcripts order in the vector, but when, at the next k-mer transcript order is relaxed and positions move, particularly where the significant majority of positions move it is indicative that the intra transcript k-mer condition is relative to other transcript k-mers in the vector. The more and the further transcripts move positions in the vector the more relevant their intra transcript k-mer relationships are likely to be to gene.

This transcript comparative presents a new method for diagnosis and therapy because each new transcript, when compared to the consensus set has the capacity to disrupt order in the vector and yield k-mers that are specifically relevant to the gene. In our assay testing we were able to predict and synthesize ncRNA sequences that significantly reduced proliferation of HeLa cells. In our pre-clinical work, based on comparisons to transcripts of the TP53 consensus we will be predicting the efficacy of cell and tissue selections that educate and activate Natural Killer cells.

Pre-clinical flow chart to educate NK cells with tumor tissue/cell co-cultures and prove prediction

  

Synapses By p53 And CD40L in Reproduction and Immunity

Cell membranes constitute a diverse range of lipid molecules each attached to a varying, odd or even length hydrocarbon chain (a tail) that, collectively pack together to form a membrane. Packing is a dynamic that generally occurs according to surrounding pressure, concentration, hydrophobic conditions and motion. The mix of molecules and their hydrocarbon chains in each membrane play a crucial role in determining functions of complex organisms in cells.

Two complex membrane bound organisms of eukaryotic cells are mitochondria - primary provider of ATP energy powering reactions of the cell and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) - protein folding organelle surrounding the nucleus. The mitochondria comprise a double membrane containing electron transport chains - sets of four membrane bound proteins which pump protons between inner and outer membranes to maintain optimal inner mitochondrial membrane pressure through which oxygen is metabolized into water by phosphorylation of ADP to ATP molecules, which are the basic energy unit of the cell.

ER is a convoluted extension of the nucleus membrane into which translated amino acids are transported and where they fold before being released and packaged in the golgi apparatus and cytoplasm. The process of translation, folding and transport requires significant energy as such mitochondria and ER are closely associated. Recently and for the first time C18 ceramide transportation between ER and outer mitochondrial membrane was described as a cellular stress response mechanism.

Another important membrane lipid C16-ceramide was found to tightly bind within the p53 DNA-binding domain. This interaction was highly selective toward the C16 ceramide acyl chain length with its C10 atom being proximal to Ser240 and Ser241. This binding stabilized p53 and disrupted its complex with E3 ligase MDM2 leading to the p53 accumulation, nuclear translocation and activation of downstream targets. The p53-MDM2 axis has been extensively covered in previous articles describing allorecognition, reproduction, immunity and auto-regulation. Ser241 was the only residue that interacted with all three p53 DNA sequences (p21, puma and a non-specific DNA system) persistently, indicating that Ser241 is a [response element] sequence-independent H-bond donor/acceptor for DNA.

It was also determined that Folate stress induces apoptosis via p53-dependent de novo Ceramide synthesis and up-regulation of Ceramide synthase 6 [C16], which is a transcriptional target of p53. In particular, Folate metabolism affects ovarian function, implantation, embryogenesis and the entire process of pregnancy. We observed that folate withdrawal leads to CerS6 up-regulation and C16-ceramide accumulation in a p53-dependent manner as a pro-apoptotic cue.

It has been demonstrated that clustering of the CD40 receptor depends on reciprocal clustering of the CD40 ligand, which is mediated by an association with p53, a translocation of acid sphingomyelinase (ASM) to the cell membrane, activation of the ASM (enzyme for ceramide), and a formation of ceramide. Ceramide appears to modify preexisting sphingolipid-rich membrane microdomains to fuse and form ceramide-enriched signaling platforms that serve to cluster CD40 ligand. Genetic deficiency of p53 or ASM or disruption of [C16] ceramide-enriched membrane domains prevents clustering of CD40 ligand. If the ligand is membrane-bound, the contact site between clustered ligands and receptors forms an immune synapse.

Finally, immune activation during the implantation phase causes preeclampsia-like symptoms via the CD40–CD40 ligand pathway in pregnant mice. The CD40 ligand (CD40L) is expressed by T cells and has a critical role in immune system regulation. Interventions targeting CD40L interactions following embryo implantation represent an approach to preventing preeclampsia (PE).

Here we have demonstrated a relationship between p53, C16 ceramide in reproduction and immunity via CD40 receptor-ligand in membrane bound concentrations of cells, particularly in respect of immunological synapse formation and blastocyst implantation. This further supports the notion that immunity and reproduction share common innate origins linked by p53.

A p53 Checkpoint For Cancer Therapy

Enormously complex signaling exists in the communication of antigens, receptors and ligands in DNA pathways between Natural Killer cells (NK) and target cells with which they interact. Based on observations, following NK formation of an immune synapse with its target cell two outcomes occur most often, termination or differentiation. The innate immune system comprises multiple cell types that are present and differentiated in tissues, but the predatory-like activity of NK has led to the general perception of its role in the immune system's front line.

As we have articulated many times on this blog, immunity and reproduction are tied, originally through allorecognition to the conserved p53-mdm2 axis. Further, it has become abundantly clear that auto-regulation of p53 occurs in multiple gene positive and negative feedback loops including mdm2. NK performance in young versus older patients showed a reduced capacity for, synaptic polarization and perforin release into the immune synapse before killing target cell. Further that the reduced release of perforin also reduced the capacity for NK to clear senescent cells associated with aging.

The activation of mitogen‐activated protein kinases (MAPK) is critical for lytic granule (perforin-granzyme) polarization, granule exocytosis and NK Cytotoxicity. It is possible that these proximal signalling events are compromised by aging. In addition, the studied p53 mutants regulated MAP2K3 gene whereas ectopic expression rescued the proliferative defect induced by mutant p53 knockdown.

In one series of experiments it was shown that the mutational status of p53 can facilitate cytotoxicity and different T cell recognition patterns. The p53 protein is presented by MHC molecules and the differential T cell recognition patterns seem confined to p53 as an antigen. The paper suggests p53 may behave differently to other classical tumor antigens, therefore a biomarker for immunotherapy targeting p53 should be the type of mutation expressed rather than protein levels only.

As previously reported, cytoskeleton superfamily member Talin1 has been uniquely tied to two essential NK functions;  activation of LFA1, required for binding ICAM on NK target cell and NK polarization that results. We know overexpression of talin head activates LFA1 and talin1 promotes cell proliferation by affecting the expression of BCL2 family and p53 network. But, mdm2 the conserved nemesis of p53 is neutralized by Merlin, another cytoskeleton superfamily protein also required for polarization. p53 also regulates the highly conserved Cdc42 which effects adhesion, actin cytoskeletal dynamics and cell movement including for angiogenesis in developing tumor microenvironments.

We found that activation of p53 augmented NK cell-mediated cytolysis of tumor cells via induction of ULBP2 expression on tumor cell surface. Further, we identified p53 as a direct transcriptional regulator of ULBP2 via an intron1 binding site, thus revealing previously unknown molecular mechanism controlling NKG2D ligand transcription. In mouse NK cells, talin is required for outside signaling by LFA1, which together with signaling by NKG2D induces granule polarization.

The functions of p53 are inextricably linked to multiple mechanisms in NK and target cells including recognition, antigen-receptor-ligand binding, cytoskeletal rearrangement, immune synapse, granzyme and perforin release. p53's mutation frequency and variances bearing p53 destabilizing mutations are recognized more effectively by p53-specific T cells than stabilized p53 mutants. Therefore, NK could operate its probe as a binding cipher that determines whether its target can be killed. Variable binding, and ectopic expression, resulting from a p53 feedback loop could be dependent on a p53 variable-kill-checkpoint that triggers the cascade of coordinated activities between NK and its target, generally referenced in the preceding paragraphs.

NK's p53 status, a targets MHC molecules presenting p53 antigens, ULBP2-NKG2D binding and relevant pathways confer with observations that the period of NK engagement is sufficient to allow downstream DNA transcription and translation to confirm and enable the kill event. Co-culture methods that could educate NK to better synchronize with targets, based on p53 status may usher in new regimes for organic immunotherapy. The Codondex research teams at Precision Autology are progressing through pre-clinical research using their computed cell selections.